Fruity Piña Colada Sandwiches

Vegetarian Badge
Fruity Pina Colada ice cream Sandwiches
Hands On:
20 minutes
Total Time:
140 minutes


  • 1 (1 pt.) container dairy-free coconut milk vanilla bean frozen dessert, softened
  • 1 tbsp rum-flavored extract
  • 8 (½-inch thick) fresh pineapple rings
  • 2 cups fruit-flavored puffed rice cereal
  • 1 ½ cups Hy-Vee creamy white vanilla baking chips
  • 4 Hy-Vee maraschino cherries with stems, for garnish
Add Ingredients to Cart


Transfer softened dessert to a medium bowl. Stir in rum-flavored extract. Place in freezer for 2 hours or until frozen.
Line a large baking sheet with parchment paper. Place 4 pineapple rings onto prepared baking sheet. Divide and scoop frozen dessert into 4 portions; place on the pineapple rings. Top with remaining pineapple rings; press down gently. Freeze for 2 hours or until completely frozen.
Place cereal in a shallow bowl; set aside. Place baking chips in microwave-safe small bowl. Microwave on HIGH at 30-second intervals or until melted, stirring each time. Working quickly, dip top and bottom pineapple rings on each ice cream sandwich into the melted chips, then immediately into the cereal to coat. Freeze until set. Garnish with cherries, if desired.

Nutrition Facts

Serves: 4
Amount Per Serving
% Daily Value*
Total Fat: 31g 40%
Saturated Fat: 27g
Trans Fat: 0g
Cholesterol: 0mg 0%
Sodium: 110mg 5%
Total Carbohydrate: 102g 37%
Dietary Fiber: 2g 7%
Sugars: 87g 174%
Protein: 8g 16%

Similar Recipes

Bowl of Rainbow Chow

Rainbow Chow

Do you love making peanut butter and chocolate chow? Try this colorful take that uses colored gelatin dessert powder to achieve all the colors and flavors of the rainbow!
Vegetarian Badge
Raisin Bran Blueberry Yogurt Bark

Raisin Bran Blueberry Yogurt Bark

Trick the kiddos into eating this healthier frozen snack that's packed with healthy yogurt, cereal, and blueberries. You'll love how easy this yogurt bark is to make!
Vegetarian Badge
Bowl of Birthday Cake Cereal Clusters

Birthday Cake Cereal Clusters

Looking for a fun and pink snack for a birthday party or baby shower? With cereal, you’ll have birthday cake-flavored clusters everyone will be munching on.
Vegetarian Badge
Plate of Air Fried Buffalo Chicken Tenders

Air-Fried Buffalo Chicken Tenders

Corn flakes cereal is the secret to these extra crispy air-fried buffalo chicken tenders.
Cereal Milk Pops emerging from pile of cereal

Cereal Milk Pops

Instead of dessert for breakfast, how about breakfast for dessert? Kids and adults will love these creamy pops made from cereal milk and topped with additional crunchy cereal.
Vegetarian Badge
Mexican Hot Chocolate Crunch Cookies

Mexican Hot Chocolate Crunch Cookies

These chocolate cookies are made from chocolate puffed rice cereal which adds a crunchy texture you won't be able to get enough off!
Vegetarian Badge
Coconut Mango Ice Cream

Coconut-Rum Mango Ice Cream

An ice cream recipe without an ice cream maker? We’ve got you! Try this creamy mango ice cream flavored with dark rum or rum flavoring.
Gluten Free Badge
Grilled Bananas Foster

Grilled Bananas Foster

Brown sugar and butter carmelize the bananas, grilled to achieve the perfect texture. Top the warm bananas with a decadent rum sauce and ice cream that garnishes Hy-Vee Bakery chocolate picnic cake!